Writing a useful review
- You were there. The review is about your own dealings with the company (a purchase, a booking, a job you hired it for or a quote you requested) within roughly the past few years.
- Details over adjectives. Say what you bought or had done, whether the final price matched the quote, whether it arrived or was finished on time, and how any problem was handled. Facts like these tell the next customer more than praise or anger.
- Fair, even when you are annoyed. Describe what happened and how you were treated. A strong opinion is fine; an insult is not.
- The right length. Somewhere between 40 and 3,000 characters.
What gets turned down
We do not publish:
- reviews by employees, relatives or paid agents of the company, or of a competitor;
- reviews given in return for a reward of any kind, such as a discount, a gift, money or a prize-draw entry;
- reviews aimed at the wrong party, such as a different business, the maker of a product, someone selling on a marketplace, or the payment provider;
- a second review of the same company by the same person within 30 days;
- anything that lets readers reach someone directly: web links, phone numbers and email addresses, and any employee’s full name or contact details;
- abuse in any form: threatening or harassing someone, hateful language, sexual material, or swearing directed at a person;
- text copied from somewhere else, or generated with AI tools instead of describing what happened to you;
- accusations of crimes. Take those to the authorities; describing what happened to you is still fine.
What businesses must not do
Asking every customer for a review is welcome. A business may not:
- reward customers for reviewing, whether for any review or for positive ones only;
- invite only satisfied customers, or put off dissatisfied ones;
- review itself or a competitor, directly or through staff, relatives or an agency;
- lean on a reviewer, by pressure or by threats, to alter or take down what they wrote.
These rules mirror the Federal Trade Commission’s consumer review rule (16 CFR Part 465). Any review gained by breaking them is taken down.
When we say no
No review written on Firsthand Report goes live before a moderator has read it. When one is turned down, the reason is recorded. Think we made a mistake? Write to us with the company’s name and the email address you used, and the review will get a second look.