What happens after you post
- You send the review. It is held as pending and nobody else can see it yet.
- A moderator compares it with the review guidelines, then publishes it or turns it down.
- Once published, it shows on the company’s page and counts toward the score. Pending and rejected reviews do neither.
What the moderator checks
- The reviewer dealt with this company directly, through an order, a booking, a visit or a request for a quote.
- Text that cannot be published is cut before the review goes live, such as a phone number, a link, a staff member’s personal details, a threat or hate speech.
- We watch for the same person posting more than once, and for reviews that come from a company’s employees or rivals.
- Each person may review a given company once in any 30-day period.
A critical review goes through exactly the same steps as a glowing one. The company it concerns may post a public answer under it, but has no way to edit, hide or delete it, and no payment changes how it is treated.
Working out a score
Add up the stars of every published review, divide by the number of those reviews and round to one decimal: that is the score. There is no estimate in it, no weighting for payment and no manual adjustment.
While a company has fewer than 5 published reviews, its score is printed on grey and labeled provisional, because a few reviews can move it a long way. From 5 reviews on it is printed on petrol and falls into one of these five bands:
| Band | Scores from | How it looks |
|---|---|---|
| Very positive | 4.5 – 5.0 | 4.7 |
| Positive | 4.0 – 4.4 | 4.2 |
| Mixed | 3.0 – 3.9 | 3.4 |
| Negative | 2.0 – 2.9 | 2.5 |
| Very negative | below 2.0 | 1.6 |
Separate figures for sales and service
Each reviewer tells us what kind of contact they had: a purchase, a quote or inquiry, or a service or repair. Where enough of them answer, the company’s page splits the score into Sales and Service, since a business can sell well and repair badly, or the other way around.
Detail scores and price questions
Reviewers may also score four details (clear communication, price fairness, timing and process, end result) and answer two yes-or-no questions about price: “Did the amount you paid match the quote?” and “Did any unexpected charges appear on the bill?” None of these figures is shown until 5 customers have answered that question.
Ordering lists by score
When a list is ordered by score, the order uses a ranking value that also weighs how many reviews stand behind the score; otherwise three five-star reviews would sit above forty strong ones. The ranking treats every company as if it began with 5 placeholder reviews of 3.5 stars each. Its real reviews then pull the value toward its actual average, more firmly the more of them there are:
ranking value = (3.5 × 5 + total stars received) ÷ (5 + reviews received)
This value is used for ordering only. A company’s own page always shows the straightforward average.
Source lines explained
The line under each review says where it came from:
- Posted directly on Firsthand Report: the customer wrote it here, on this site.
- Reported through the company's own feedback form: the company gathered it from its own customers and handed it to us. Feedback that the company picked out, edited or paid for is never accepted.
- From another review platform: the customer first posted it on a different review site, and it appears here exactly as it was published there. These reviews carry no source line.
Company listings
Each listing starts from business details we gather and verify: the name, street address, phone number and website. If a business closes, or its details can no longer be confirmed, the listing is hidden rather than deleted, so the reviews on it are preserved.
A company may claim its listing at no charge, which lets it correct its details and answer customers. A claimed listing keeps exactly the score it had.
If a review looks wrong
Under each review is a Flag link. Use it when a review breaks the guidelines, concerns a different company, or seems not to be genuine. A moderator looks at every flag and then removes the review, leaves it up, or asks its author for more detail. A flagged review stays visible while this happens.